News - 10 September 2024 16:00

Tight labour markets threaten EU growth, innovation and long-term goals

Prolonged labour shortages in the EU affect growth, innovation and the bloc’s ability to achieve its digital and green targets, as around 80% of EU employers struggle to recruit workers with the right skills. Currently, the skills of one in three employees in the EU are mismatched with their job, with 17% overqualified and 13% underqualified.

Eurofound's new report Company practices to tackle labour shortages provides updated evidence on the persistence of labour shortages amid declining levels of labour market slack in the EU and at Member State level, and details organisational policies aimed at attracting workers to occupations in which shortages are common.

In addition to broader impacts on economic growth and innovation, the report notes that labour shortages can also have profound implications for working conditions, as existing workforce experience intensified work, increasing the likelihood of stress and burnout, leading to absences and exits that exacerbate the situation.

Eurofound analysis indicates that job vacancies in the EU have increasingly been filled by workers moving jobs, thereby gaining better wages and conditions, rather than by unemployed people entering employment. This could signal ineffective activation policies, particularly for those outside the labour market or underemployed. At the same time, more remains to be done to update education and initial vocational training curricula and invest in ongoing training.

In 2023, a quarter of EU companies were forced to recruit workers without the required skills. An additional 18% report fewer than one in five recruits having the necessary skills. Many employers have adapted positively to increasingly focus on marketing and employer branding, offering better pay, and non-wage benefits in order to ensure recruitment and employee retention.

Labour market slack data suggest that employers still rely largely on a constant pool of labour. There is not enough being done to address shortages, and further actions are required to engage groups outside the labour market, as well as to enable involuntary part-time workers to work additional hours. This requires enhanced public policy regarding care provision; integrating people not in employment, education or training (NEET) and people with disabilities; and introducing more effective targeted activation policies, for example for low-skilled and migrant workers.

The report notes the importance of effectively integrating Ukrainian refugees and third country migrants by addressing barriers to sustainable recruitment, including avoiding skills underutilisation. Solutions include streamlining processes to regularly update the identification of shortage occupations for the purposes of granting work permits to third-country nationals, as well as the recognition of qualifications gained abroad and the offer of language training and integration services with the involvement of the social partners.

Overall public policy intervention relating to labour shortages should be combined with the greater involvement of the social partners and employers, since among the latter active engagement with the integration of underutilised groups is currently more limited.

Download the report: Company practices to tackle labour shortages

Additional data:

Topics

James Higgins

Press contact Communication Officer jhi@eurofound.europa.eu +353-1-204-3100

Måns Mårtensson

Press contact Media & Promotion Manager Media relations, marketing and promotion mma@eurofound.europa.eu +353-1-204 3124

Eurofound analyses labour shortages in Luxembourg

Labour shortages in Luxembourg were analysed in an information session on National policy and company approaches to addressing shortages at Eurofound this week. These exchanges, known as Virtual Visits, take place in the context of Eurofound’s ongoing efforts to reach out to the national level and ensure widespread dissemination and dialogue with respect to its research findings.

Job retention schemes saved close to 27 million jobs during the pandemic

Job retention schemes, one of the main policy tools used during the COVID-19 pandemic to safeguard jobs and protect incomes, saved 26.9 million jobs in the EU in 2020 and 2021.The schemes also reduced inequality by 0.15 percentage points, and lowered the at-risk-of-poverty rate by 0.5 percentage points.

Urban and capital areas continue economic and employment dominance

Urban and capital areas have disproportionately benefitted from the digital revolution in Europe, with a high rate of knowledge and service-based jobs. By comparison, many rural areas risk being left behind, with unbalanced urban economic dominance further deepening urban-rural divides.

Growth in human capital helping to overcome economic divergence in Europe

Human capital - defined as the knowledge, skills and other attributes that enable people to be productive - played a role in EU convergence in respect of national income over 2014–2021. Specifically, highly educated individuals have helped central and eastern EU Member States and regions to catch up with their western counterparts in terms of gross domestic product (GDP) per capita.

National legislation struggling to adapt to the rise of cyberbullying at work in Europe

Workplace cyberbullying or ‘digital harassment’ is only explicitly covered in regulatory frameworks in Denmark in the EU, with other Member States either attempting to extend legal definitions to include misconduct occurring through information and communication technologies (ICTs) or outside of the physical workplace; or lacking any definition of workplace bullying or harassment in law.

EU lack of labour won't be solved by skills alone: Improving job quality is key

While an initiative such as the European Year of Skills is welcome, and improving skills can certainly go some way to help to address labour shortages, it is not a silver bullet. To address these challenges effectively, what is needed is a clear grasp of the drivers behind shortages in specific sectors and occupations and the policy context.